The 3 Best Italian Restaurants in Guelph [2024]

Guelph’s Italian dining scene is bustling with spots that make every meal an occasion. From irresistible pizzas baked to perfection in wood-burning ovens to pastas that taste like they’ve been simmered in tradition, we’ve traversed the city to bring you a taste of Italy right here in Guelph. Here’s a closer look at the three best Italian restaurants that promise a dining experience as authentic and warm as the Italian sun.

And if you’re looking for more great places to eat, be sure to check out:

Best Italian Restaurants in Cambridge
Best French Restaurants In Kitchener
Best Bakeries In Guelph
Best Halal Restaurants In Guelph


Why Italian Cuisine Captivates the Heart

Italian cuisine is more than food; it’s an expression of a culture that values quality, simplicity, and the joy of gathering around the table. With an emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients and time-honored cooking techniques, Italian food offers a delightful journey through flavors that are at once comforting and exhilarating.

The Best Italian Restaurants in Guelph

1) Buon Gusto Restaurant

At Buon Gusto, every dish speaks of authenticity and culinary excellence. We witnessed the way they cherish simplicity, using locally sourced ingredients to bring traditional Italian pizzas and pastas to life. The heart of the restaurant is its Tuscany-made wood-burning oven, promising a slice of Neapolitan paradise in Guelph.

Business Information:

Phone: +15192658766
Address: 69 Wyndham St N, Guelph, ON N1H 6P6, Canada

Customer Review:

“My experience was beyond amazing at buon gusto. Dave was spectacular and showed us such good service he was nothing but friendly and welcoming. Our server was also amazing and experience was amazing.  I would 100% come back again.”

“Still the place to go for great Italian food in Guelph. Service is amazing and I Love the place.”

2) Manhattan's

Stepping into Manhattan’s is like finding a hidden Italian gem in Guelph. Their bustling atmosphere blends perfectly with the sophisticated yet comforting dishes, delighting patrons with a robust menu that sings of Italy’s culinary diversity. Here, food and jazz create a symphony that’s truly irresistible.

Business Information:

Phone: +15197672440
Address: 951 Gordon St, Guelph, ON N1G 4S1, Canada

Customer Review:

“Great jazz going on Friday night. Love the atmosphere.  A fantastic staff very friendly makes you feel like family immediately. If you never been to Manhattans you are missing a Guelph GEM. Oh food was marvelous.”

“Food tasted amazing, the hanger steak was cooked perfectly. Service was also very friendly and often checked in, very friendly feel to everyone. Atmosphere was fantastic, very cool design inside and we went on a night where they had a pianist performing both modern and older songs and he was great. Highly recommended this place if you’re in Guelph and thinking about somewhere new or a new date night type place.”

3) Sugo on Surrey

Sugo on Surrey offers a contemporary twist on classic Italian dining. The inviting ambiance complements their innovative dishes, which we found to be a beautiful blend of tradition and modernity. It’s clear from the glowing testimonials that Sugo isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a vibrant culinary hub for Italian food aficionados.

Business Information:

Phone: +15192655532
Address: 117 Surrey St E, Guelph, ON N1H 3P7, Canada

Customer Review:

“Everything we had was prepared very well and tasted amazing. Service was prompt and excellent. Really enjoyed our visit!”

“Very cozy restaurant and excellent food! We had the pork belly, the pistacchio pizza and the rigatoni with shrimps. Everything was delicious, we will definitely be back!”

FAQs About Best Italian Restaurants in Guelph

Yes, each restaurant features gluten-free choices, accommodating various dietary needs with the same Italian flair.

Certainly! Buon Gusto, Manhattan’s, and Sugo on Surrey offer delicious vegetarian and select vegan options that celebrate Italian cuisine’s versatility.

Yes, especially on weekends or for large groups, reservations are advisable to ensure a seamless dining experience.

While they aim for a welcoming atmosphere, smart casual attire is appreciated to match the elegant yet relaxed dining ambiance.

Final Thoughts

Buon Gusto, Manhattan’s, and Sugo on Surrey each bring a slice of Italy to Guelph, offering unforgettable dining experiences that resonate with the essence of Italian cuisine. Whether you’re craving a classic pizza, in search of innovative Italian dishes, or looking to enjoy an evening of fine dining, these spots promise to delight your palate and warm your heart. Buon Appetito!

The 3 Best Japanese Restaurants In Guelph [2024]

The 3 Best Indoor Playgrounds In Guelph [2024]